Crossed Fields

Bodies · mechanical systems

charges B=1  Ey=0.2
m=0.1  q=0.1  x=-2  y=1.5  vx=s
m=0.1  q=-0.1  x=-2  y=-1.5  vx=s

Open in the app The dials and keys named below are the app's.

The setup

Two charges of mass 0.1 start at (−2, 1.5) and (−2, −1.5), carrying +0.1 and −0.1. Both move along x at speed s, a slider that opens at −0.4, backwards. The first line, charges B=1 Ey=0.2, puts them in a magnetic field of 1 pointing up out of the floor and an electric field of 0.2 along y.

The drift

Seen from a frame moving along x at E/B = 0.2, the electric field disappears. There the magnetic force on that motion, q · v × B, cancels q·E exactly. So in that frame each charge simply circles, once every 2π·m / (q·B) ≈ 6.3 seconds at Speed 1.

On the floor that circle is carried along at 0.2, and the path is a trochoid. The drift is E × B, which holds no charge and no mass. A negative charge feels both forces reversed, so it drifts the same way at the same speed, looping the other way round. Both move along x at 0.19 over 20 seconds, each partner's pull taking a little off the field.

The loops

At s = −0.4 a charge runs at −0.6 against the drifting frame. It circles there with radius m·0.6 / (q·B) = 0.6, faster than the drift, so its path loops back on itself. The positive charge's loops reach 2.69 above the axis, and the negative one mirrors them below.

History

Wilhelm Wien built crossed electric and magnetic fields into a filter in 1898, to study anode rays. Only a particle moving at exactly E/B feels the two forces cancel and passes straight through; every other speed is deflected.

Try

  • Drag s to 0.2, the drift speed. Both charges go almost straight, staying within 0.02 of where they started across, as in Wien's filter.
  • Drag s to 0. Starting from rest, each path is a row of cusps, arching about 0.4 away from the line they sit on.
  • Write Ey=-0.2 on the first line. E × B now points along −x, and both charges drift off to the left together.
  • Press Top to see the loops flat, one row above the axis and its mirror below.

Read more

Bodies · mechanical systems